Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Personal VIRTU3

The three domains of VITRU3 show up in many other areas of human action. The table below shows how some important conflicts and differences of opinion map back to fundamental disagreements about the nature of virtue. The columns represent the three absolutist stances on each of the different topics. More complex, nuanced views would apply to the three blindnesses. A full understanding of VIRTU3 comes from synthesizing these views without compromising any of them.

INTENTIONS ACTIONS RESULTS
DOMAIN Moral Ethical Consequential
PLUS/MINUS Good/Bad Right/Wrong Positive/Negative
CATEGORY Belief Theory History
TIME The Future The Present The Past
SPACE Hearts and Minds The World of Forms The Real World
HIGHEST
VALUE
Ideals Truth Experience
MEASURE OF SUCCESS Popularity Wisdom Prosperity
BASIS Self-Knowledge Human Nature Observed Results
STYLE OF
REASONING
Intuitive Deductive Inductive
FAILURE
MODE
Self-Delusion Logical Fallacies Black Swans
SOURCE OF
ERROR
Belief ≠ Reality Theory ≠ Reality Data ≠ Reality
MORAL
PHILOSOPHY
Intentionalism Natural Law Utilitarianism
SCIENTIFIC
PRIORITY
Social
Advancement
Procedural
Correctness
Practical
Utility
JUDICIAL
EMPHASIS
Mens Rea Fault-Based
Liability
No-Fault
Liability
RELIGIOUS
FOCUS
Divine
Grace
Divine
Justice
Divine
Favor
ECONOMIC
TOOLS
Economic
Philosophy
Economic
Praxeology
Econometric
Analysis
POLITICAL
NARRATIVES
Aspirational Rational Pragmatic
AMERICAN
POLITICS
Democratic
Party
Liberty
Movement
Republican
Party
POLITICAL
ECONOMICS
Socialism Voluntaryism Capitalism
POLITICAL
HIERARCHY
Progressive
Meritocracy
Associative
Individualism
Traditional
Aristocracy
POLITICAL
POWER-GROUP
Scientific-Technical
Elite
Guerilla
Patriot-Terrorists
Military-Industrial
Complex
POLITICAL
FAILURE MODE
Totalitarian
Communism
Feudal
Anarchy
Totalitarian
Fascism

No comments:

Post a Comment